Linked In
News In
Linked In

You are viewing your 1 complimentary article.

Register now to receive full access.

Already registered?

Login | Join us now

Opinion: Nufarm deal doubts look overdone

Twitter Linkedin eCard

Steady on, mate. Investors are wise to keep a wide margin for error when considering whether Sinochem's approach to Australia's Nufarm will end in a deal.

But the 13% discount they are allowing to Chinese group's Aus$2.8bn (US$2.4bn) bid may be overcautious.

Surprise surprise

Sure, pessimists have an arsenal of arguments on their side. Nufarm's last approach - also from China - fell through two years ago for reasons that have never been explained.

There's no guarantee that Sinochem's bid won't follow suit. The Chinese chemical giant isn't tied into a deal. Its legal obligations thus far stretch to undertaking due diligence of the Australian chemicals group in good faith.

Nufarm's numbers have surprised even its own managers this year. The company followed up a rights issue in May, when it said trading was "reasonable", with two profits warnings a month later. (And another alert six weeks after that).

It isn't difficult to imagine Sinochem finding something to take issue with.

Rival bid?

Nor can investors bank on a counterbid.

Analysts have suggested a ream of names as potential buyers in the past, including America's Monsanto and Swiss-based Syngenta.

None have yet stepped forward.

If there are rival suitors around, they are keeping their cards close to their chest.

Rising tide

But even if Nufarm does end up remaining independent, it is not certain that investors have a huge amount to lose.

The fair value of the shares is Aus$10.70, according to Deutsche Bank, less than 7% below Tuesday's closing price of Aus$11.43.

Indeed, Nufarm shares might have approached that kind of level even without Sinochem's help. Sydney stocks have been on a roll since the Sinochem bid was revealed, jumping 17%.


Conversely, there is the potential for a big profit. Factoring in a dividend payment, Sinochem's current proposal would give buyers of Nufarm shares at Aus$11.43 a return of 15%.

That's good going, even though investors wouldn't get their money for a while. As currently conceived, Sinochem and Nufarm won't sign an implementation agreement until December.

Chinese companies have begun to look more serious buyers, even during the two months that the Sinochem-Nufarm deal has been gestating.

Even doubting investors might be best off keeping some skin in the game.

By By Mike Verdin

Twitter Linkedin eCard
Related Stories

Deere lifts sales hopes - even as it unveils biggest loss in 25 years

The maker of John Deere tractors flags "strengthening" market conditions, but swallows a huge writedown prompted by US tax retorms

Plant Impact agrees takeover by Croda, after failure of Bayer contract

The crop enhancement group, floored by the failure of a supply deal with Bayer, agrees a takeover by a maker of chemicals from anti-wrinkle creams to floor coatings

Cautions mount over cost to US agriculture of trucking safety clampdown

US officials reference tightened trucking rules in a cotton export forecast downgrade, while Tyson Foods forecasts an extra $200m in costs

Evening markets: Wheat futures soar to multi-month highs - but China fears undermine soy

Wheat futures jump, boosted by chart appeal, and worries over US dryness. Corn sets a six-month top too. But soy’s rally falters
Home | About | RSS | Commodities | Companies | Markets | Legal disclaimer | Privacy policy | Contact

Our Brands: Comtell | Feedinfo | FGInsight

© 2017 and Agrimoney are trademarks of Agrimoney Ltd
Agrimoney is part of AgriBriefing Ltd
Agrimoney Ltd is registered in England & Wales. Registered number: 09239069