Linked In
News In
Linked In

You are viewing your 1 complimentary article.

Register now to receive full access.

Already registered?

Login | Join us now

Opinion: Sinochem-Nufarm deal looks tricky

Twitter Linkedin eCard

The land down under is trying another attempt to turn the form book upside down.

Australia has done a pretty good job so far at keeping foreign bidders pouring in, despite global economic recession and domestic climatic risks.

If it isn't the Brits (Terra Firma) buying the Packers all but out of cattle ranching, it is the Canadians (Viterra) muscling into Australian cereals handling through the purchase of ABB Grain.

Now China's Sinochem has appeared on the doorstep, taking a pop at Nufarm, the agrichemicals giant.

Easy matches

This tie-up, however, looks a far more troubled bet.

The problem is the number of hoops a takeover would have to jump through.

One big advantage of the Packer and ABB deals was that they were struck between willing sellers and enthusiastic, and experienced, buyers.

It's not obvious that Sinochem-Nufarm ticks these boxes.

Troubled history

Chinese bidders have a habit of fluffing overseas bids - often thanks to intervention by foreign authorities, as famously scuppered CNOOC's potential investment in US Chevron, but not always.

Shareholders did for the Chinalco-Rio Tinto tie-up, while a series of proposals have foundered for unknown reasons, such as the failure of a China-led consortium to buy Nufarm two years ago.

While their record has improved recently, Sinochem hardly inspires confidence of being a winning suitor. Its successful purchases have tended to be relatively small – a Yemen oil operation for $465m last year, a South Korean refiner in 2005 for $552m.

Nufarm is a bigger catch, at some Aus$3.4bn (US$2.8bn) including debt.

Rathbone factor

And it is not clear that this fish wants to be fried. That matters when Nufarm's chief executive, Doug Rathbone, is also its biggest shareholder, with more than 11% of the stock.

It is difficult to determine exactly where he is taking the company.

Indeed, the group's recent record of a rights issue, a profits warnings, maybe another one and an approach revealed only under pressure from Australian authorities has led Credit Suisse to question "management/board integrity".

But to be sure, it would hurt Mr Rathbone to accept a bid near the current price of Aus$10.66 when the Aus$17.25 a share the Chinese were offering him two years values his stake Aus$160m higher.

Long list

Especially so when there are plenty of other deep-pocketed companies - including Monsanto and Syngenta – have in the past been rumoured as likely suitors too.

The Nufarm and Sinochem relationship may yet be the one to end in embrace. But do not expect the course of this affair to run smooth.


Twitter Linkedin eCard
Related Stories

Evening markets: Soybean futures gain, cotton prices jump on US data

Initial USDA forecasts for crop supply and demand for 2018-19 lift soy and cotton prices, but are not so well received in the cotton market

Will protein prices fight back against fat in dairy markets?

Prices of fats remain elevated against protein values in dairy - at a time when the opposite is true in markets for oilseed products

Weekly grain market view from Europe, February 23

EU cold snap could damage crops... UK market prices in closure of Vivergo ethanol plant... Rising Russian wheat prices...

Evening markets: Argentine moisture slips up soymeal rally. But weather revives wheat

Meal futures dip, a little, for the first time in 12 sessions. But wheat futures gain, as drought spreads in Kansas, and cold reaches Europe
Home | About | RSS | Commodities | Companies | Markets | Legal disclaimer | Privacy policy | Contact

Our Brands: Comtell | Feedinfo | FGInsight

© 2017 and Agrimoney are trademarks of Agrimoney Ltd
Agrimoney is part of AgriBriefing Ltd
Agrimoney Ltd is registered in England & Wales. Registered number: 09239069