Linked In
News In
Linked In

You are viewing your 1 complimentary article.

Register now to receive full access.

Already registered?

Login | Join us now

Opinion: potash groups come to their senses

Twitter Linkedin eCard

If it looks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it is a duck, the saying goes.

So do not be befuddled into thinking that the agreement by PotashCorp and its North American kin to sell potash at $460 a tonne to India is anything but a climbdown.

It looks like one – the Canpotex potash export consortium, of which PotashCorp is a member, had been holding out for north of $600 a tonne.

And it quacks like one. Or, in the words of Sterne Agee, the broker: "Canpotex finally got in line behind smaller producers, to avoid being completely shut out of India."

PotashCorp is entitled to its opinion that the Canpotex deal, and similarly priced ones before it from the likes of Russia's Silvinit, show "customer understanding of the premium value" of potash.

Others may believe that potash producers have come to understand the importance of having customers.

Share price danger

It would be interesting to know which of the forces ranged against Canpotex finally tipped the balance.

Was it the record decline in North American potash applications? The appreciation that farmers really will not pay up for potash, given the credit crunch's grip on their purse strings and with crop prices treading levels of one half of last year's peak?

Was it the fall in fertilizer groups' share prices – a risk when mining groups may have their eyes on potash prey?

Vale's reported interest in Mosaic, another Canpotex member, followed lingering rumours that Anglo-Australian BHP Billiton covets PotashCorp, whose shares up until Thursday had dropped by 25% in six weeks.

Disunity risk

Maybe it was the appreciation that the global potash "alliance" is not as indomitable is it had thought.

That, as Opec the oil cartel has often realised, self-interest is a powerful counterweight to teamwork.

And that global pricing discipline was unlikely to hold for ever and, once broken - by Silvinit on this occasion - would be hellish difficult to repair.

'Noble cause'

Whatever, the important factor is that the impasse has been broken. And, indeed, it looks like something of a win-win deal.

Farmers get cheaper potash to pursue what PotashCorp boss Mr Doyle terms their "noble cause".

Fertilizer groups get their cashflows moving again, and can avoid the expense of mothballing further capacity, let alone the embarrassment of further profit warnings to follow the two PotashCorp alone has already delivered this year.

Indeed, the market reaction was to send fertilizer groups' shares up 7%. Now that wasn't so painful, was it?


Twitter Linkedin eCard
Related Stories

Evening markets: India emerges as surprise ag market mover, lifting cotton

... while fuelling a decline in in sugar prices. In grains, soybeans stage some revival on a drier trend in the Argentine outlook, but wheat proves mixed

Dairy prices find calm at GDT, as investors await milk production signals

Skim milk prices correct their unexpected surge of the last session, while whole milk powder values avoid the tumble suggested by futures values

Morning markets: Wheat futures stage notable rebound. Other ags less so

Downbeat US crop ratings help wheat futures to respectable revivals, after the last session’s plunge. But trade war worries slow corn, soy, cotton recoveries

Evening markets: Wheat futures plunge limit down, as funds close ag bets en masse

Hard red winter wheat tumbles 6.0% at one point, after rains refresh US crops. Argentine rains hurt soybeans too. But fund flight benefits some ags
Home | About | RSS | Commodities | Companies | Markets | Legal disclaimer | Privacy policy | Contact

Our Brands: Comtell | Feedinfo | FGInsight

© 2017 and Agrimoney are trademarks of Agrimoney Ltd
Agrimoney is part of AgriBriefing Ltd
Agrimoney Ltd is registered in England & Wales. Registered number: 09239069