Linked In
News In
Linked In

You are viewing 1 of your 2 complimentary articles.

Register now to receive full access.

Already registered?

Login | Join us now

Opinion: the silver lining to dismal crop prices

Twitter Linkedin

Every cloud has a silver lining. Even the one which has been sat over agricultural commodity markets.

It has certainly been a difficult time for crops' champions, bar those prescient enough to see the sugar squeeze coming.

The big grains, weighed down by huge harvests, have been the laughing stock of the investment community.

Winners and losers


Gold bugs have pocketed a rise of about 15% this year, oil prices have jumped by more than a half. Equity investors have enjoyed a recovery of more than 8% in New York and 10% in London, with dividends on top.

The figures for crops make less appealing reading. Chicago soybeans are down 6%, corn has lost 17%, while wheat has slumped up to 30%, depending on the exchange.

The difference between crops and the rest has been particularly marked since the spring,  when shares, oil and gold began significant upticks.

Which is quite the point. At some point, shares will at best slowdown, and potentially suffer a marked correction, if history is a guide. And when they do, crops' lack of correlation leaves them well placed to attract fast money.

Lessons from history 

Shares certainly look vulnerable. A look at rebounds from great bear runs past shows that, with a few exceptions, equity rallies suffer marked setbacks.

In some cases, these have wiped out recoveries, and more, as with Wall Street's first stab in 1929-30 at recovering from the Great Crash. Then a five-month rally of 47% was followed by a two-year slump in which shares lost 83%.

In other instances, stocks have held on to regained ground only to mark time, as after the 1974-75 rally. Then a 54% rebound over nine months was followed by a bear market that lasted the rest of the decade.

There is a notable exception, 1982, when shares bounced, and kept going. But conditions then, with interest rates falling from longstanding and high levels, appear to bear little relations to today's.

Contrary indicator


As it is, at seven months old, this rally is already pretty long in the tooth. And it is flagging what some would see as signs of overheating.

One is the apparent capitulation of bearish investors, who seem to have given up calling the top of the market.

Another is that, in the UK at least, small investors have begun investing in levels not seen since the technology boom. Their zealousness has been a pretty accurate harbinger of disaster since before the Great Crash.

Investors' alternatives


The question for crop investors is where money will go when equities do run out of steam.

Oil looks a poor bet. It has lost its historic ability to move in opposite direction to shares, questioning its use as any kind of safe haven from an equities storm, according to Jeremy Siegel of the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School.

Bonds look the wrong turn in what may become an inflationary environment.

Even gold has shown signs of moving in time with equities, Mr Siegel says.

That is not a charge that can be laid at the door of farm commodities. Their refusal to join in this year's recovery party may allow them the last laugh.

By Mike Verdin

External web links

Twitter Linkedin
Related Stories

Hedge funds turn net bullish on ags - ahead of price drop to historic low

Speculators are wrong-footed in soymeal, in which they hike bullish bets just before a price tumble. But they fare better in cotton and cocoa

December makes poor stab of bringing festive cheer to ag bulls

This might have been the month when grain prices began a "breakout", higher. Instead, ag prices are hitting their lowest in at least 26 years

Morning markets: Wheat futures set fresh contract low

... dragging on the corn market, amid selling ahead of a key US report. The Argentine weather outlook depresses soybean prices

Soft commodities better bets than grains for 2018, says Commerzbank

Indeed, investors are overrating prospects for corn and wheat futures. But cocoa futures have scope for gains, and coffee could see a "price surge"
Home | About | RSS | Commodities | Companies | Markets | Legal disclaimer | Privacy policy | Contact

© 2017 and Agrimoney are trademarks of Agrimoney Ltd
Agrimoney is part of the Briefing Media group
Agrimoney Ltd is registered in England & Wales. Registered number: 09239069